ezekiel's chariot - 張敦楷 ([info]pjammer) wrote,
@ 2008-01-03 08:11:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current location:Fort Bragg, CA
Current mood: productive
Current music:Billy Idol - White Wedding
Entry tags:essays

White Privilege Counter-Meme
So it seems the 'privilege meme' (authored by Will Barrett) has been making the rounds; people bold the things that are true about their upbringing from this list as a way to showcase how much 'privilege' (read: unfair advantage) they had over their peers - perhaps supposed to feel guilty about it?

As an immigrant for whom English is my THIRD language (and whose parents started over in their mid-30s in a new country with a new language), the entire excercise irritates me on so many levels I felt the need to create a counter-meme. The truth is, by global standards, EVERYONE who just lives in the westernized world is absurdly privileged, and it is incredibly destructive to focus on the miniscule 'unfairness' of how so-and-so got to go to a museum as a kid, and you didn't.

Go through the list below. Bold the stuff that's true about you.

Or I'll make it easy on you and just list the stuff that's UNtrue.

Poverty

1 Unlike 50% of the world, I have always had access to clean, potable water.
2 I don't know anyone who does NOT have access to clean, potable water, and until I read the above, did not know the percentage of world population that does not have this benefit.
3 I don't know anyone who died from malaria.
4 I don't know anyone who died from malnutrition.
5 I don't know anyone living on less than US$1000 per year.
 

Government, Education, Internet

6 I live in a country where the average citizen has a life expectancy over age 40.
7 I live in a country that has a literacy rate of over 95%.
8 I have a connection to the Internet either personally or through a library in my city, and through that, can access the repository of the world's knowledge with a few keystrokes.
9 My country does not enact nationwide internet censorship and will not forbid me from reading articles or posting comments critical of my country's leaders or policies.
10 My country does not jail or execute citizens who express dissent with its current leaders or government policy.
11 From age six to eighteen, I have access to a public education system that is free to residents of my community.
 

White, Heterosexual Males (others, please skip down to next section)

12 If I am financially successful, I am told the only reason I have a comfortable lifestyle is because of my 'white privilege' - any hard work, risk-taking or personal work ethic I applied to better myself during my schooling or career is discounted. I am obligated to 'share the wealth' and endure confiscatory taxes of my income and investments as 'reparations' to nonwhite strangers I'm presumed to have oppressed on my way to to top.
13 If I am financially/professionally unsuccessful, I am solely responsible for my failures and can expect to be openly ridiculed by mainstream culture ('hick' 'poor white trash' etc).
14 I must never acknowledge reverse-racism/anti-white discrimination; the existence of women-only fitness clubs, race-gerrymandered college admissions or government set-aside contracts for less-qualified competitors are all legitimate recourse against centuries of oppression perpetrated by people of my skin tone/gender.
 

NON-White Heterosexual Males (N-WHM)

15 If I start a business, there exists an entire federal bureau dedicated to granting me access to capital, consulting and mentoring, based on my ethnicity or gender.
16 There exists advocacy groups of my specific ethnicity/gender/sexual orientation, who strongarm special privileges for my group from governments and give me access to free legal and media representation if I ever feel aggrieved by a WHM and wish to make a big to-do about it.
17 There exists Oppression Studies majors at most universities where students can earn bachelor's and even advanced degrees just by studying/cataloging how those with my ethnicity/gender/sexual orientation don't have it as good as WHMs.
18 If I, as a minority, express an opinion skeptical of the notion of 'white privilege,' I will be scolded as a 'self-hating [minority type]' who has 'internalized my oppression;' there is only one correct opinion to have on the matter and if I dissent, I can expect to be branded a 'race traitor.'

Site Meter


Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>

(Post a new comment)


[info]shamroq
2008-01-03 04:49 pm UTC (link)
They see caucasian
They hatin
Try to catch me rollin' white & uppity

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]warpedpuppy, 2008-01-03 07:59 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]ikilled007, 2008-01-03 11:16 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]kitiara, 2008-01-04 01:43 am UTC (Expand)

[info]stormsigma
2008-01-03 04:50 pm UTC (link)
This was absolutely spectacular, I must say.

(Reply to this)


[info]nelliebelle
2008-01-03 04:57 pm UTC (link)
thanks for this :)

i was feeling sorry for myself for only finding 5 of the 30-whatever privileged middle class items true for myself, but this definitely puts it in perspective. although, i haven't always had access to clean, potable water!

(Reply to this)


[info]007zed
2008-01-03 05:00 pm UTC (link)
Well said, well researched.

(Reply to this)


[info]teriel
2008-01-03 05:01 pm UTC (link)
Thank you

(Reply to this)


[info]infrogmation
2008-01-03 05:10 pm UTC (link)
My thought on first seeing the meme was along the lines of:

When you grew up, did you:
1)Have indoor plumbing?
2)More often than not have enough to eat?
3)Have armed groups actively trying to kill you and your family?

If yes, yes, and no, you're priviledged.

One thing that still amazes me about the USA is that we have POOR PEOPLE with indoor plumbing, tvs, and automobiles.

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]thomasngo, 2008-01-03 05:41 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]jauncourt, 2008-01-03 08:15 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 08:20 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]jauncourt, 2008-01-03 08:25 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 09:25 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]jauncourt, 2008-01-03 09:41 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-04 12:01 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]ikilled007, 2008-01-03 11:18 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]vaquera, 2008-01-04 04:25 am UTC (Expand)

[info]solis93
2008-01-03 05:22 pm UTC (link)
The truth is, by global standards, EVERYONE who just lives in the westernized world is absurdly privileged, and it is incredibly destructive to focus on the miniscule 'unfairness' of how so-and-so got to go to a museum as a kid, and you didn't.

By globals standards. Sure. If you live in poverty in the US, you make $16,000 per year and have a roof over your head you are privileged compared to third world countries. But in a country like this, which boasts being the best and the richest, where all men are treated equal to some degree, for there to be any poverty at all is completely fucked up. We have the power to end hunger world wide, but it isn't done why?

I am sorry, but this rebuttal to a ridiculous privileged meme is just as ridiculous and myopic. Oh, and #15 is subject to the color or flavor of the day. #18 shows his motivation.

The facts are what they are. Poverty is more prevalent in places where there is a lack of education, nutrition and opportunities. What a coincidence that the majority of those people are people of color.

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]perich, 2008-01-03 05:35 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-03 05:41 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]rainbow_goddess, 2008-01-03 06:10 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]radiantsun, 2008-01-03 08:20 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]ikilled007, 2008-01-03 11:23 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]radiantsun, 2008-01-03 11:28 pm UTC (Expand)
try living where there is no grocery store. - [info]jsl32, 2008-01-05 12:23 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 08:28 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-03 08:31 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]rainbow_goddess, 2008-01-03 08:39 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 09:14 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 09:07 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 09:19 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:06 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]ikilled007, 2008-01-03 11:24 pm UTC (Expand)
you don't cheat your own-- you cheat the other guy. - [info]jsl32, 2008-01-05 01:22 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 09:57 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:16 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]ikilled007, 2008-01-03 11:22 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]geah, 2008-01-04 02:08 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]rainbow_goddess, 2008-01-04 02:35 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]layo, 2008-01-03 06:19 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]solis93, 2008-01-03 07:29 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:01 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]solis93, 2008-01-03 10:03 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:20 pm UTC (Expand)

(Deleted post)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:34 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:35 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-03 08:12 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]gargamehl, 2008-01-04 02:48 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-06 04:24 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]gargamehl, 2008-01-07 06:13 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]layo, 2008-01-04 07:14 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]radiantsun, 2008-01-03 08:27 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 10:02 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]layo, 2008-01-04 07:16 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-04 10:14 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - (Anonymous), 2008-01-11 03:40 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]miss_skillet, 2008-01-04 06:28 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]layo, 2008-01-04 07:19 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]solis93, 2008-01-03 07:25 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-03 08:23 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]solis93, 2008-01-03 10:00 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 11:13 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-04 01:57 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]solis93, 2008-01-04 02:59 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-04 04:12 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-03 09:58 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]ikilled007, 2008-01-03 11:28 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 11:58 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]geah, 2008-01-04 02:22 am UTC (Expand)

[info]mikailborg
2008-01-03 05:24 pm UTC (link)
I'm quite glad you posted this, and am thinking of linking future posters of that other meme to this entry.

I was thinking of making a much shorter one:

1. I have the Internet access necessary to read this.

I mean, that covers a lot of bases in today's world, right there.

(Reply to this)


[info]cluebyfour
2008-01-03 05:32 pm UTC (link)
Haha. Touché.

(Reply to this)


[info]perich
2008-01-03 05:34 pm UTC (link)
You had me until this:

I must never acknowledge reverse-racism/anti-white discrimination

q.v. this.

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]elefuntboy, 2008-01-04 05:30 pm UTC (Expand)
Yep ...
[info]btripp
2008-01-03 05:35 pm UTC (link)
Needless to say, as a white, middle-aged, middle-class Male (hell, with at least two Mayflower ancestors), I am encouraged to read something like this ... it's hard to "fight upstream" against all the "new cultural bias" that's developed since the 60's, and this is (obviously) something that somebody like me would get savaged were I to have posted!


Visit the BTRIPP home page!



(Reply to this)


[info]perich
2008-01-03 05:41 pm UTC (link)
I'm not even sure what the point of #12-18 is, unless it's "If you live in a country that has the luxury of being able to analyze racial and cultural trends, rather than a country where such trends are enforced at AK-47-point, you're privileged." To which I agree without question.

(Reply to this)


(Anonymous)
2008-01-03 05:54 pm UTC (link)
You are correct in pointing out the privilege we all have. Your post is a bit schizophrenic though - the first bullet points admit privilege and the last ones deny it - or at least point out the ridiculousness of trying to split hairs in defining the level of privilege we all have. It's humbling and none of us really do enough to help those less privileged. I'm not talking about being white, or American,(or male, which I am not) but just in being human, we should all do more to help the other humans. It really boils down to this simple truth - there are always people in society that get more for reasons other then their hard work, and others who get less because of it. The humanitarian in me thinks this is wrong, however; I would not be willing to give up what I have, all of which is due to privilege and my opportunity to build upon that privilege with hard work. If you look at the big picture, you could actually say that the suffering of my fellow humans in the poverty that exists in much of the world is a sacrifice made to elevate the most privileged humans to the highest level of social, intellectual, and spiritual evolution possible, thus making that sacrifice worth it since it serves the greater good. This line of thinking leads to the conclusion that we (as privileged humans) have an obligation to make the best of ourselves and give something back. Perhaps my thought process is just my aristocratic liberal Californian knee jerk reaction but it's one way to make myself feel a bit more entitled to all that I have.
--Shelly Harrington

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]9thmoon, 2008-01-03 11:11 pm UTC (Expand)

[info]candid
2008-01-03 06:21 pm UTC (link)
Race traitor.

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-03 08:55 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]candid, 2008-01-03 08:57 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]uke, 2008-01-03 09:24 pm UTC (Expand)

[info]wakeuplovely
2008-01-03 06:37 pm UTC (link)
very well written and thought provoking.

(Reply to this)


[info]palecur
2008-01-03 06:45 pm UTC (link)
Thanks for posting this! You did a better and blunter job than I'd have been able to without offending several people I care about, and responses to nuisance memes aren't worth the local drama.
As someone 2 generations removed from Andean peasantry, the whine the white guilt laser makes while it's spinning up to operating temperature can get kind of grating.

Edited at 2008-01-03 08:30 pm UTC

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-04 02:08 am UTC (Expand)

[info]palecur
2008-01-03 06:48 pm UTC (link)
also, that's an EVE icon, or I miss my bet. you still playing?

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]pjammer, 2008-01-03 08:29 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]palecur, 2008-01-03 08:33 pm UTC (Expand)

[info]radiantsun
2008-01-03 07:49 pm UTC (link)
I ignored the privilege meme because I thought it was dumb (someone later mentioned it was more abou class than privilege), and I didn't care about sharing any of it, and I skipped reading all but the controversy about the meme's existence. My first response to seeing it was: who cares if my parents read to me? I don't even remember.

I have mixed feelings on the concept of privilege, because on one hand, it is something that may be there, on the other hand it is also something that is made a bigger deal out of than exists . . .

I had to write a paper on how I'm privileged for school. I didn't do very well on it because I felt almost the entire time like I was grasping at straws. It didn't help that my teacher hated white people. I wish I could get APB and Khiem to give talks on overcoming racism.

I am more likely to judge someone based on how they dress and the content of their speech than what color they are. My step-grandmother, would, however, refer to anyone not white as "those people" and she gets upset when there is a female minister speaking at her church (it's a white man's job dontcha know).

I also tend to think that beleiving that racism/sexism is rampant influences one's perceptions of how they are being treated in the world-- i.e. increases the perception that things are slights, that are not actually slights, which then changes their behavior etc.

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

Go Buy Some More Books, Cracka - [info]shamroq, 2008-01-03 08:16 pm UTC (Expand)
Re: Go Buy Some More Books, Cracka - [info]radiantsun, 2008-01-03 08:35 pm UTC (Expand)
Re: Go Buy Some More Books, Cracka - [info]rasputen, 2008-01-03 11:05 pm UTC (Expand)

[info]touchstoneaf
2008-01-03 08:25 pm UTC (link)
WELL done!
Having lived in Zimbabwe, I found this counter-meme a breath of fresh air!

Thank you.

(Reply to this)


[info]kenshi
2008-01-03 08:31 pm UTC (link)
WIN.

(Reply to this)

PWNAGE
[info]ikilled007
2008-01-03 11:13 pm UTC (link)
Perfect.

(Reply to this)


[info]thomasngo
2008-01-03 11:31 pm UTC (link)
This was interesting until I hit 12-18. The original meme overgeneralized how access to certain resources could lead to success, but yours goes one step further in creating false dichotomies.

People's hard work and abilities enable them to rise to the top. By abilities, I mean the things that you already had a natural inclination for (nature) and were developed (nurture). What the original meme did was try to look at the resources available to you in your upbringing. Race and gender are correlated with those resources.

Of course the problem with that is by making distinctions based on race and gender, broad and sweeping generalizations about people are made. These are the same generalizations that you're outraged about. I understand that and think that you raise an important counterpoint that should be addressed.

What disturbs me most is number 12. To participate in The United States of America, land of liberty, means making small individual sacrifices for greater individual freedoms. Everybody knows the principle of marginal utility — that giving a dollar to a rich person is worth less than a dollar to a poor person. The poor person will likely buy more food. The rich person may just put it towards tipping the doorman.

A healthy democracy requires that high income earners give a larger percentage of their income because they are much more able to do so. High income earners may think they "need" certain things, like a few more Zegna suits to impress their clients. But that could feed many hungry children. Yes, there are plenty of hungry children in America; and unfortunately we feed them some of the most unnutritious crap thanks to special interest food subsidies.

Even if you argue that money left in the private sector would generate more money that could lift more people out of poverty, the problem is that it isn't made compulsory. You aren't required to give money to charities. You're taxed.

The paradox about the United States is that people believe it is the land of opportunity (it is compared to developing countries). But class mobility is much higher in Scandinavian countries, known for having higher taxes and more public services. Also, present generations in the US are less likely to transcend the classes they were raised in.

It is my view that the pursuit of money and things has gotten confused with the pursuit of happiness in this country. This country is steeped in a culture of materialism and of buying more than you can afford. You stereotype poor blacks as buying dub-dubs, well I can stereotype poor whites as buying RVs and other useless junk. Creating demand for things you don't need and manufacturing consent for things that are bad for you (i.e., abolishing estate taxes) seems to be what characterizes American culture.

People's choices aren't always rational. Their class has a huge role to play in how they behave and function in society. One of the main factors contributing to generational poverty is the culture of not saving. The only reason why some cultures are more immune to it is because they have had less exposure to all this consumerist bullshit.

And where does this culture of consumerism originate from? You could say that the people who willingly partake in buying more stuff are at fault. But what happens when you sit people in front of a TV telling you that you need this and that? You program them.

CONTINUED...

(Reply to this)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-04 12:07 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]thomasngo, 2008-01-04 01:47 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-04 02:12 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]thomasngo, 2008-01-04 02:30 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]foobiwan, 2008-01-04 02:43 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]thomasngo, 2008-01-04 02:54 am UTC (