
aturday, 8:30 pm. I'm lost in old memories, tipsy on old wine, with a glass in my hand and a heart full of sorrow. I’m drinking tonight. I’m drinking to the magic we’ll never make. To the kisses we will never share. To the nights I’ll never feel her breath on my ear as we sleep in the quiet hours before dawn. I’m at a wedding of two old college friends that I drove hundreds of miles to witness. My mood should be celebratory, but fool that I am, took a detour a few hours earlier to visit an old flame. Like summer rain sweeping everything in its wake, memories of sweet yesterdays pour forth as I walk the chapel steps outside the reception hall.
It’s cold tonight. Clouds roll in the night sky slashing the empty canvas of stars above me with streaks of curling gray vapor-trails, illuminated by a silver gibbous moon.
Old Ghosts
How does any tale of misfortune and loss begin? It begins when we least expect it, neh? It begins in winter four years ago - back in my final year in college - back in my happier yesterdays when the future was so pregnant with possibility.
Garrison Keillor once said, when asked if it was appropriate for a girl to kiss on the first date: "You should never go out on a date with anyone you didn’t want to kiss in the first twenty minutes."
But is it possible to connect deeply within a brief encounter? It's rare, but it can happen. Naïve and gullible people call it "love at first sight," but that’s not quite right. The more accurate description of that experience is ‘synchronicity of idiosyncrasies’; that recognition when you see significant pieces of yourself reflected in the soul of another - pieces that you believed all your life you’d never see in anyone other than yourself. It’s a wondrous, giddy feeling and a joy you hope you can hold close to you forever.
And, during winter 1997, this is when I met Caroline. Caroline with the broad friendly smile and gorgeous dimples, Caroline with the spirited tenderness and cheerful optimism, Caroline with the fiercely brilliant mind and an admission letter to one of the top medical schools in the nation, Caroline with a role as my spouse in a drama production we were both a part of.
Within minutes of meeting, she verbally tore into me - shredding the façade I wear to the world, playfully poking and bantering as if we old friends ... and I responded in kind. And oh, the energy of the exchange - rapid-fire dialogue shifting between English and Mandarin was like some deranged sweeps-week-quality multilingual episode of "Friends." Sharp wit, beautiful smile, bilingual Chinese speaker, and the fact that our very first encounter paired us up as a married couple.
Synchronicity? You're soaking in it.
Heaven have mercy on fools, I was smitten.
And the sun shone brightly on us in the weeks that followed - near-daily encounters for conversation (always great conversation) and shared meals, and talks from the serious and complex, to the absurd and silly, talks that regularly draw past the midnight hours. And that smile - that dimpled smile that lights up a room. And in my giddiness I told her a story I kept close to my heart all these years.
(continued from page 1)
Story Within a Story - Of Chinese Mythology and Legends
Note: I'm going to have to offer a translated iteration of the tale here. Alas, the English version does rob some of its power and beauty, but it's the best I can do - and will be vitally relevant, as will be seen shortly.
In the beginning of the world, there was an old man assigned to create the souls of those who would populate the earth. He would knead the clay and create little figures in pairs, male and female, connected by a red thread that he would use to hang them upside-down to dry. When his work was finished, the thread, from the left foot of one and the right foot of the other, would be severed and the souls would be sent to populate the earth, where they spend a lifetime finding the one they were connected to at their creation. This is what we call yuen.
Xian shu, shi yuen chi. Xian tze, shi yuen hsu, Xian feng, shi yuen ding.
Yuen is a word rich in meaning that translates poorly to English. The best way to think of it is as the intersection between the words "fate," "chance," "destiny," and "opportunity." Not a coincidence that left side of the yuen character is the root/radical for "thread." Yuen is said to have depth and length - you cannot change whose family you were born into, you cannot choose the people you run across in this lifetime, but you can strengthen and deepen the connection you have ...or let pride, grudge matches and thoughtlessness wither those threads away. And this is the connection - from one person to another, two souls speaking in synchronicity when you find your other half and take the effort to cultivate and cherish the moments you can create with one another.
All's Fair in Love and War
Ah, but all good things must end, don't they? The gods of irony are never far away from where I roam - stalking me from triumph to tragedy, ever-ready to pop out like an evil jack-in-the-box when I least expect it. An attractive woman is bound to have a past and Caroline was no exception - at the impressionable age of 20, she was seduced by a 31-year-old balding virgin accountant, and maintained contact off and on in the time we had together. When you have a string of lame boyfriends behind you, even the most unimpressively mediocre thirtysomething man looks mature by way of comparison. But the damage was done. Imprinting did what charisma cannot. Scientists first discovered "imprinting," when they studied baby ducks - a phenomenon where ducklings would devote unswerving loyalty to the first thing they see, be it a person, toy doll or, in the wild, their mother. Look around and you can see that imprinting happens for many humans as well.
As it turned out, the presence of serious competitor for Caroline's affections was just the kick in the pants the sandbagger needed to realize that he wasn't going to get any better than her - and he quickly proposed ... and the one move I as a college student couldn't possibly counter. How ironic that it was likely my increasingly intimate interactions that catalyzed the chain of events leading to her engagement. So I graduated with a heavy heart - and I knew I lost her forever when she told me she was going to live with her fiancée while attending medical school - lost her to the fact that I didn't meet her a year earlier, lost her to a monolingual old man who had no interest learning the language or culture she and I both live and breathe.
Pjammer: King of Masochists
So it's 2001. I'm driving to San Diego to see two old college friends marry and figured to visit as many other friends as possible during the trip. College buddies. Email pen pals. My brother at his dorm.
And, oh yes. Pjammer (you, dumbass, you) also calls up a certain now-married woman he hasn't seen in years to meet for lunch. She's as beautiful as ever, as sardonic as ever ... and now bears the surname of the old man who outmaneuvered me all those years ago. We talked like old times - about life, about school, about my time overseas ... and ... about married life.
"Remember that story you told me about the thread and the souls?"
"Sure."
Where was she going with this?
"I used it at my wedding and everyone loved it."
"..."
Oh Caroline, you didn't.
It was all I could do to hold my face reactionless that day ... because I couldn't tell you anything without me breaking down completely. It hurt so much I wanted to cry, but I kept smiling because sharing those things now would have done us no good. I've lost you already, and heaping guilt on your shoulders is something I couldn't bear to do.
But I told you the tale because in my heart of hearts I believed it was our story - yours and mine. I told you because in the time we had, I lived to hear your laughter, felt joy when you were elated, and suffered in moments of your disappointments. I told you because of all the people I've been involved with, you are the one I remember most fondly.
You gave away the story that should have been ours - and by necessity had to butcher it in its translation for this monolingual interloper, this sandbagging gweilo who wouldn't have had a chance with a women of your caliber his own age. And your eyes were so bright from recounting the memory of your unknowing betrayal I couldn't bear to tell you how wounded and violated your words left me. It's pointless to disclose such things and burden you with my grief - so I will take my sorrow and bury it in the secret places next to the shards of my broken heart. I will bury it with such a smile on my face so that you will never know.
I never told you how much I treasured your company in the moments when I was graced with your affection.
I never told you the crushing devastation I felt when I lost you.
I never told you how many nights I spent in the darkness cursing God, Allah, Yahweh - whatever, for showing me the possibility of perfection, dangling it before my eyes and then snatching it away from me.
Oh Caroline, sweet Caroline - I never told you so much, and perhaps I should have.
But I never will.
It's 10 o'clock. Revelers are straggling out and the happy sounds of wedding celebration can still be heard from the inside of the chapel. I'll go back for a last toast to old friends in a moment, but I pause to take one last look at a photograph of the two of us in a happier season before returning it to my billfold.
The air is still cold, and I still am alone.
P.S. Sandy Ego, Caroline - a followup ten years after we parted ways - where I mull over whether to accept her invitation for dinner when I am in San Diego in December 2007.
P.P.S. Alethia, G.A. Caroline Aftermath, update to the above update.
← Ctrl← Alt
Ctrl →Alt →
June 26 2001, 17:55:58 UTC 10 years ago
Memories.....
To read that was beautiful......and bittersweet.~wisteria
June 26 2001, 18:44:18 UTC 10 years ago
June 26 2001, 18:55:17 UTC 10 years ago
Thank you
... for your kind words. Link away. I publish online instead of offsite for a reason. :)June 26 2001, 20:00:50 UTC 10 years ago
Keeping my comments to the point...
Thanks for sharing this. It was something very special to read on a dreary winter afternoon.-Nick
January 20 2007, 13:28:11 UTC 5 years ago
all
helloJune 26 2001, 20:02:50 UTC 10 years ago
i love it....the stuff u write is absolutely amazing....you must think a lot...and reminisce a lot...
June 26 2001, 20:21:46 UTC 10 years ago
June 26 2001, 20:28:53 UTC 10 years ago
June 26 2001, 20:50:53 UTC 10 years ago
I enjoyed reading this very much ... thank you for sharing it !!
June 26 2001, 20:51:04 UTC 10 years ago
and sad.
beautifully sad.
June 26 2001, 21:40:32 UTC 10 years ago
Wish I could offer good consolation
Stunning and graceful, touched my heart it did...Wow, how could she have overlooked you? Still, it almost seems as if something is missing from the story, too magical and one-sided....maybe it's just me, but it seems like you're holding back something about her?
Still, I wish it had turned out better for you. Her naivete to the weight you placed on your time together hurts the most; one day I hope you meet someone who can appreciate the time you spend with them.
June 27 2001, 03:48:43 UTC 10 years ago
Bravo.
It's always the best ones that get away.:'(
Maybe perfection is just too scary.
/A
June 27 2001, 06:11:55 UTC 10 years ago
June 27 2001, 10:28:36 UTC 10 years ago
Does she lack perception?
She sounds amazing, bright, brilliant, beautiful. I can see where she'd be hard to replace. But I still have to ask myself how amazing could she be to "give away" your story and then blithly brag to you about it. Is she misreading your signals, past and present, so completely? Or is her nonchalant description of the vows actually a backhanded jab at you, because when she was ready for marriage all those years ago, you weren't, and couldn't respond appropriately. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the pressure to get married in even transatlantic Chinese homes is almost too much for a young girl to handle. She may be carrying her share of regrets too.June 27 2001, 11:36:17 UTC 10 years ago
i must agree with cleacat
how can someone so perceptive use your tender and fairly obviously metaphorical story so offhandedly? Let me be the one to say that you might actually be better off.I can't see how she could hear that story and not realize the import of it's content, and then knowing that use it blatantly in another circumstance. And then to come and offer you the tale of it's success as some pale consolation prize? Pjammer, we're not going to let you walk away empty handed! we're going to cut off your hands!) Personally, i think you were spared from her by the gods i don't believe in, so that you can find someone who knows what to make of your talents.
June 27 2001, 21:36:11 UTC 10 years ago
Questions & Answers
Ok, questions from a few posters - let's see if I can tackle them all in one entry here.Pochacco:
How could she have overlooked you?
I have courted, loved and lost women for almost a decade yet female psychology still perplexes me. I think in this case incumbancy trumped connection - he was there first and she attached a lot of significant moments in her life to his company. Imprinting is a vicious thing, isn't it?
... it seems like you're holding back something about her?
Her past loomed in the background as a constant presence - and for all the passion, connection and synchronicity we shared - I was not ready for what she wanted. I was all of 23 - and lived in the world of ramen and student loans. My immediate rival lived in the world of 401(k)s, home-purchases and steady paychecks. Yes - status matters. Status can make an ugly man handsome, and money can make a boorish fool seem a gentleman. Unfair? Most certainly. Realistic? I'm afraid so.
Cleacat:
Is she misreading your signals, past and present, so completely?
I wish I could tell you. I can be empathic enough in business and social situations to profile a person's psychological map with stunning efficiently. But in romantic scenarios, I am, as I was at 19, a hopeless thumbsucking amateur.
Or is her nonchalant description of the vows actually a backhanded jab at you, because when she was ready for marriage all those years ago, you weren't, and couldn't respond appropriately.
Possibly. I certainly wasn't ready for marriage then - and I hardly feel emotionally mature for those responsibilities right now. But I don't think she has a vindictive nature, and I doubt it was consciously intended as a jab (although it most certainly had that effect).
saint_monkey:
How can someone so perceptive use your tender and fairly obviously metaphorical story so offhandedly?
I don't know. If I really understood female psychology, I'd be writing this to you from my private island in the Carribean with a Midori Sour in one hand while getting a backrub from my gorgeous soulmate.
And then to come and offer you the tale of it's success as some pale consolation prize?
That was the cruelest blow - watching my best and most meaningfrul anecdote hijacked, butchered and served to a guy who wouldn't even do the courtesy of learning a second language in the name of cultural understanding/communication. I wish I could tell you a good 'why' - but there's only one person who can answer that question.
And I'd never ask.
10 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
June 27 2001, 14:42:22 UTC 10 years ago
By the way, one of Plato's dialogues (I can't recall which one offhand) tells a story remarkably similar to the story about the thread. It was probably derived from your story, which I assume is significantly older.
Anonymous
August 7 2001, 09:52:43 UTC 10 years ago
The Dialogue was...
Plato's Symposium.June 27 2001, 18:34:54 UTC 10 years ago
I sat at the edge of the Pacific, green and white sand between my toes. Sometimes, from that beach, you could make out the shore of Maui-- just barely visible through the clouds. There I'd talked to him for hours and hours, my voice lulling him to sleep. He told me it drove away the bitterness of Boston's winter nights.
We couldn't have been further apart. We couldn't have been closer together.
To say that I loved him is inadequate. For a time I dwelt in him, and he in me. I breathed him in, drunk on every stifled sigh. We danced angels on the heads of pins, sharpened our tongues on each others' wits. We talked about the tattered dreams we were clinging to, and made fun of our own pain. We laughed until our throats were sore and our phone bills crippling.
We battled even at our best moments, raided each other-- wrenching from each other grief which we'd hoarded for years, months, or moments.
True honesty is a narcotic, which becomes more dangerous and more addictive the more powerfully it comes.
The sun was almost gone beneath the waves. He whispered, "I love you," and my breath caught in my throat.
It wasn't the first time I'd heard it, and it would be far from the last. There was nothing special about it which, on an objective set of merits, might set it apart from any other.
Before I had time to muddle out how I felt, he was strangling on a suffix. "-- as a friend."
He needed to heal, and I understood it. So I smiled, cradled the phone against my shoulder and shook my head to the empty air. "No need to explain it," I purred. "You shouldn't keep from saying it if it wants to be said. I love you as a friend as well. I think I always have."
He asked me to sing him to sleep. I chose a song one of our local bands had covered, spun a softer sound around. Most of the songs I knew at the time were love songs... they suited the silvery soprano at which my voice won contests, and I was proud of that at the time. He didn't just listen-- he never just listened. Half-spoken words tumbled like prayers from his lips to the phone... words that melt a woman's reason, like 'beautiful' and 'amazing.' I think it had more to do with the fact that a woman /would/ sing for him than with any talent of mine.
That is why things are so much more magical and meaningful at those ages, I think. Little blessings could still be amazing. We could still remember never thinking we might see them for ourselves, much less grow to think of them as trite and routine.
Part of me knew his praise was not even half-deserved. I soaked it up nonetheless, and drew my strength from those moments.
By the time I finished, he was murmuring nonsense under his breath. The phone call was wearing into the early morning where he was. He geared up his courage, and started to say something, but I stopped him. "Go to bed," I whispered.
The moment was too strange, and we were both feeling too weak. Nothing could be said in a right mind.
He obeyed.
We went on like this for weeks, but a chain reaction had begun. It got harder and harder for him to tack 'as a friend' on the end of those whispers. "Each time I'd say it," he eventually revealed, "I'd want to stop right there. I'd beg you to stop me. But you never did."
How do you explain that? How do you explain caring so deeply about a person that you are willing to redefine love itself to accomodate his needs? Willing to accept it on any terms it gives, without even the faith that it will eventually be what you want? Willing to cherish it for just what it is?
Was he right? Did it mean I didn't really love him?
Pardon my imposition, as I dodge the buffer, and bear with me as I continue...
June 27 2001, 19:07:10 UTC 10 years ago
Posted under the thread to avoid too much spam... in futility...
On Valentine's Day, it arrived quite unexpectedly at the front desk of the Villas I called home at the time. A cut crystal vase, filled with long-stemmed red roses. It was tied with an enormous velvet bow, trimmed in satin. Luscious ferns and baby's breath made it so full it was hard to carry up the stairs. What was on the card should not be repeated-- needless to say, "as a friend" was not included.It was a betrayal of our promises so far, but not one with which I could take issue. The same day, a stuffed bear trimmed in chocolates arrived at his front door. My words were less possessive, basically declaring the kinship I felt to his heart.
From then on, he would no longer add a suffix to "I love you."
It never meant the same thing to me as it did to him, but that doesn't mean it meant any less. I don't think either of us really had time to recognize what it meant. I only know that to him it meant, "I want a future with you here as mine, and I will do whatever it takes to get that." So to him, it fell from my lips a lie.
I didn't know what we could possibly be... he wasn't my first online crush, nor even my first serious steady online relationship. But with the previous young man, I'd had family and plans that were naturally carrying me toward where he lived. It was more like a pen pal relationship than anything else, between friends separated that would be reunited.
I had nothing in Boston beyond Tom, and that weighed more heavily on his mind than I could comprehend at the time. Half the time, he seemed frightened I might not take the risk it would take to strike out for a life on my own in Boston. Half the time, he seemed frightened that I might.
The sweeter the moments we shared became, the more agonizing the moments between would be. It's not something we didn't forsee. That's why we kept bridling ourselves, kept putting blinders on to try to keep it all at bay.
Yet all the while we were nibbling at the very fruit we ourselves forbidden, dabbling in things that had become dangerous for all the meaning we laid onto them. Every word turned on us like starved hounds, ripping us to shreds with meanings we never intended. We'd end up plunging into territory we never meant to approach, and retreating in agony when we realized the misunderstandings-- each time convinced that the other didn't want it, and we were pushing it anyway.
The freedom to explore each others' sentiments was gone. We feared too much to trust. Everything seemed at once to drown us further into feelings we didn't want to explore, and sharpen the misery that came of knowing we couldn't. He couldn't stop hurting for what he couldn't have. I couldn't stop hurting for the fact that I seemed to hurt him so often.
The happiness we could have had seemed to hang like a star. "It's too much," he yelled at me. "One minute I think I'm going to be with you forever, and I can't take being apart another moment. Then I look around at this place, and I know you'll never be here. We'll never even see each other, and I can't take this any more!" Like I could reach up, and brush it with my fingers, but never feel it there-- my mind admonishing that it was a million miles away. "In the same breath, I hate you, and I love you desperately. What are you doing to me?"
I said the words over and over again, curled around my bedspread staring at a dead and broken phone. I was trying to find some meaning in them. Trying to understand what I should have said.
"I don't want to talk to you any more. I'm not going to call any more, and I don't want you to call me. This is it, kitten. We have to say good-bye. Do you understand? WE HAVE TO SAY GOOD-BYE!"
But we never said good-bye. We said, "Talk to you soon." We said, "See you online." We said, "I miss you." We said, "Good night."
We never said good-bye.
We never spoke again... (cont'd one last time)
10 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
Anonymous
10 years ago
10 years ago
5 years ago
June 28 2001, 11:08:51 UTC 10 years ago
love at first sight and other fallacies
i agree with you that there is no such thing as love at first sight... simmilar interests, hormonal fireworks, yes, but i am from the old school, and think love is when you know a persons weaknesses, as well as their strengths before factoring in the love equation.and its sad when wonderfull, intelligent women, pick older guys due to earlier issues that they havent dealt with, or even know of. i had it happen to me, because i got there too late, and i didnt want kids, and the girl wanted to be seen as something other than the girl that jumped from man to man... even though both her and i knew that this was something special, and that her relationship with her soon to be husband was one of security, and nothing more.
and her using that story was uncalled for... the simple fact that she used that with him means that maybe she wasnt as magnificent as you initially thought... the grass is always greener on the one that got away.
August 9 2001, 01:37:55 UTC 10 years ago
August 11 2001, 22:41:16 UTC 10 years ago
August 12 2001, 23:41:47 UTC 10 years ago
August 12 2001, 03:20:05 UTC 10 years ago
And although this wretched language of mine has spawned an ingenuity that has repeatedly toppled and decimated the ambitions of most asian nations, leaving the rest to grovel and beg for the scraps of my cursed Capitalist excess like the dogs that they lovingly roast for sustenance, I now realize that until the day comes that i thoroughly and completely denounce the English language, I can never truly understand LOVE or FATE or DESTINY the way they are MEANT to be understood. Further, I will personally commit myself to the task of infiltrating the diabolical, utterly psychotic CULTS of insensitive, elderly, white Americans, who, as i speak, are enslaving innocent asian girls.. dragging them kicking and screaming, against their will, to be beaten and brainwashed into denying the destinies that their cultures INTEND for them to fulfill... the solution is clear... The small, oafishly-primitive brain of an average white American simply CANNOT comprehend such difficult concepts as "love" or "culture." Thus, all interracial relationships shall be heretofore nullified... all innocent, misled asian women are to be returned immediately to their parents and re-distributed among more deserving, culturally designated partners... You must act, Sir! With success, countless individuals may be spared the wrenching pain that you have been forced to cope with by your narrow-minded, English-speaking oppressors.. Havok , I say!
August 12 2001, 17:55:26 UTC 10 years ago
Wow ...
Zounds!Loopy + Jerk + Stealth + Lonely Guy =  
So fill me in ... why list your home in "Louisiana" when you know darn well you live in California?
10 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
August 16 2001, 13:55:46 UTC 10 years ago
Oh lord
That is so sad, on so many levels.To respond to someone else's post above. I think the sad thing is that this older man doesn't want to share in something that is so important to Caroline. It's part of her roots. It's part of who she is and he doesn't want any part of it. That's sad.
September 1 2001, 03:33:48 UTC 10 years ago
......
..speechless..Anonymous
November 22 2001, 11:33:53 UTC 10 years ago
the relevance within
But is it possible to connect deeply within a brief encounter? Yes, it's rare, but can happen. Na�ve and gullible people call it "love at first sight," but that's not quite right. The more accurate description of that experience is 'synchronicity of idiosyncrasies'; that recognition when you see significant pieces of yourself reflected in the soul of another � pieces that you believed all your life you�d never see in anyone other than yourself. It�s a wondrous, giddy feeling and a joy you hope you can hold close to you forever.
I understand this, but right now I also understand far too well that it is no guarantee of a lifetime of happiness... or even so much as a single afternoon. The one with whom I have found such a connection lives on another coast, in another country, and neither of us is capable of finding a long-term solution to this obstacle. It just won't work between us. This weekend will be spent by each of us trying, in our own way, to forget, and live life apart. It is very hard. Is extirpation traumatic by nature? I just wish at this moment that my introduction to "relationships" with the opposite sex could have begun with something a little more trivial, like perhaps a short-lived mutual high school crush. That obviously wasn't in the cards. I'll go upstairs and vent in French at the ceiling, now. I've embarassed myself enough by posting my unschooled teenaged ramblings here.Anonymous
November 22 2001, 11:35:08 UTC 10 years ago
Re: the relevance within
Damn, the closing slash didn't take.Anonymous
December 19 2001, 13:36:34 UTC 10 years ago
damn
that's all i can say. damn. wonderful, lyrical, beautiful, aweinspiring words...i can't say that i've been through your situation before....but...wow. i am amazed.December 21 2001, 01:27:04 UTC 10 years ago
Re: damn
Thank you. Would you like a LJ account activation code? I'd be happy to provide one for you if you'd like.Anonymous
10 years ago
Anonymous
10 years ago
10 years ago
Anonymous
February 10 2002, 00:23:26 UTC 10 years ago
Anonymous
April 14 2002, 22:53:31 UTC 10 years ago
nice entry
hi! i just want to say, that was a very well-written entry. very touching and honest. oh, and i want to say that i love garrison keillor!! he always gave the best advice and i miss mr. blue. every day. *sniffle*10 years ago
Anonymous
August 11 2002, 12:43:27 UTC 9 years ago
Unrequited love as our common thread
I enjoyed your journal, especially the entries above your lost love.http://moonbeams.diaryland.com
← Ctrl← Alt
Ctrl →Alt →